Soliciting Money Ban Threatens Livelihoods, Sparks Outrage and Advocacy
Members of the transgender community in Pune have sought intervention from Deputy Chief Minister and Maharashtra Home Minister Devendra Fadnavis regarding a recent ban imposed by Pune city police on soliciting money at traffic signals. The ban, enforced under section 144, has drawn sharp criticism from the community, who argue that it not only jeopardizes their means of sustenance but also exacerbates existing social and economic challenges.
Expressing strong opposition to the ban, Shamibha Patil, state coordinator of Tritiya Panthi Hakka Adhikar Sangharsh Samiti, highlighted the adverse impact on transgender individuals’ livelihoods. Patil emphasized that soliciting money at traffic signals and participating in family functions for blessings have long served as vital sources of income for many transgender individuals, given the discrimination they face in employment opportunities.
Patil criticized Pune Police Commissioner Amitesh Kumar’s decision, highlighting similar unsuccessful attempts in Nagpur during his tenure as CP. Instead of a blanket ban, Patil urged for a more nuanced approach, advocating for collaboration with the Transgender Welfare Board to implement schemes supporting transgender livelihoods.
In a detailed letter to Fadnavis, Patil outlined the community’s concerns and urged the deputy chief minister to advocate for inclusive policies and uphold the dignity and rights of transgender individuals. The community plans to stage a peaceful protest outside the Pune police commissioner’s office to voice their grievances.
Echoing Patil’s sentiments, Disha Pinki Shaikh, a member of Tritiya Panthi Hakka Adhikar Sangharsh Samiti, emphasized the need for alternative livelihood systems. Shaikh warned of the potential consequences, including the risk of forced involvement in prostitution and crime, if the ban persists without viable alternatives.
Shaikh urged the police to consider the humanitarian implications and proposed a careful examination of the issue to find equitable solutions. With an estimated 3,000 to 4,000 transgender individuals in Pune, Shaikh emphasized the urgent need for policies that safeguard their livelihoods and prevent marginalization.
